The Supreme Court delivered judgment in Re S on 14th March. The appeal related to Article 13b of the 1980 Hague Convention. It is apparent from the judgment (delivered by Lord Wilson) that the court agreed to hear the appeal because they were concerned that the Court of Appeal judgment diverged in its approach from the UKSC decision in Re E and there was a danger of confusion arising as a result.
The UKSC allowed the appeal and held that the Court of Appeal had been wrong to overturn the first instance decision of Charles J which the UKSC accepted was one which he was entitled to reach on the totality of the evidence available to him. The judgment criticises the restricted focus of the Court of Appeal judgment.
At the core of the appeal was the issue of whether an abducting mother who had mental health problems needed to show there were objectively verifiable risks which would cause her mental health to deteriorate to such an extent that the child would suffer harm or whether proof that her health would in fact deteriorate was enough even though the deterioration was a result of her purely subjective perception of risk.
The UKSC re-affirmed what they said in Re E which was that if it was established that a risk to the child would arise it mattered not what the source was and thus if an individual believed they would be harmed, even if in fact objectively it was unlikely, and as a result their mental health would deteriorate that would create a risk that could be relied on.
In fact the subjective argument did not actually arise on the facts because Charles J decided that the evidence of risk was so strong that there were objectively reasonable grounds for the mother to fear she would suffer abuse on return.
The decision adds nothing new to the law on Article 13b although it does confirm that for this sort of defence to succeed there will need to be powerful evidence which would include
a) evidenceof psychiatric vulnerability predating the Hague proceedings
b) expert psychiatric evidence confirming the mental health problems, the likelihood of deterioration and the likely ineffectiveness of protective measures to prevent that deterioration.
In Re E the UKSC agreed that Pauffley J's was entitled to find that the protective measures would in fact prevent the mother's mental health deteriorating.
What some people are concerned about is the situation of primary carer abductors asserting they will not return with the child and that this will create an intolerable situation. This assertion is often heard but the judiciary have been robust in refusing to accept bare assertions of that sort. Although it will not be enough simply to say 'coach and horses' when such assertions are made (although the UKSC did not consign that argument to history) it can be expected that any such assertion should be scrutinised most carefully and that for the court to accept that the primary carer abductor will not in fact return there will need to be either strong objective evidence which would justify that decision or a determination that whether objectively justified or not the primary carer would not in fact return. It is hard to see a court accepting that without psychiatric evidence to support it in most cases. A person without mental health issues who for no good reason refused to return would find it difficult to prove that they would not, when push came to shove, return.
Although it will no doubt be used by abductors to support that sort of argument it seems unlikely those arguments will succeed save in the rarest of cases where there is strong psychiatric evidence (pre and post the Hague proceedings) to justify a decision not to return.
Observations on practice and developments in private international law relating to children and families
Showing posts with label 1980 Hague Convention. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 1980 Hague Convention. Show all posts
Thursday, 15 March 2012
Wednesday, 22 February 2012
Commission recommends the EU recognise 8 additional countries as parties to the 1980 Hague Convention.
The European Commission proposed the EU accept Russia and seven more countries as parties to the 1980 Hague Convention on child abduction. If accepted by the Council the move will effectively extend protection for children in the EU to eight new countries: Russia, Albania, Andorra, Armenia, Gabon, Morocco, Seychelles and Singapore.
Article 38(4) of the 1980 Convention stipulates that the Convention applies between the acceding country and Contracting States that declare their acceptance of the accession. Therefore, the European Union has to decide whether to accept the accession of Russia and other countries. As the matter of international child abduction falls into the exclusive external competence of the European Union, the decision whether the EU, via its Member States, should accept other countries' accession to the 1980 Convention has to be taken by means of a Council Decision.
http://europa.eu/rapid/pressReleasesAction.do?reference=IP/11/1582&format=HTML&aged=0&language=EN&guiLanguage=en
Monday, 20 February 2012
UK Supreme Court hears Re S today.
The Uk Supreme Court is hearing the case of Re S today (20th February 2012) The case concerns the approach that ought to be taken to the assessment of the evidence in cases where the Respondent relies on the Article 13b exception, particularly where the abductor relies on the impact on themself of a return. The High Court and the Court of Appeal both refer to guidance on the Article 13(b) exception given by the Supreme Court in Re E (Children) (Abduction: Custody Appeal) [2011] UKSC 27; [2012] 1 A.C. 144, including as to the potential relevance of protective measures. The main questions before the Supreme Court are (i) as to whether, and if so in what circumstances, the Article 13(b) exception can be established on the basis of the subjective perceptions of the abducting parent; and (ii) the circumstances in which an appellate court is entitled to interfere with an assessment made by the judge at first instance.
If it is televised find it on http://news.sky.com/home/supreme-court
Case information at http://www.supremecourt.gov.uk/current-cases/CCCaseDetails/case_2011_0265.html
If it is televised find it on http://news.sky.com/home/supreme-court
Case information at http://www.supremecourt.gov.uk/current-cases/CCCaseDetails/case_2011_0265.html
Tuesday, 31 January 2012
Supreme Court grant permission to appeal in abduction case.
The UK Supreme Court has granted permission to appeal in a case involving the grave risk of harm defence under Article 13b of the 1980 Hague Convention. The main point in the appeal involves a challenge to the way the Court of Appeal approached the question of harm to a child arising out of the likely impact on a mother's mental health where the impact would be caused not by an objective risk to the mother and child but because of her subjective fear of risk. In Re E (UKSC May 2011) the court appeared to approve of the proposition that the source of the harm was irrelevant if in fact it was likely to cause harm to the child but the Court of Appeal judgment suggests that the risk of harm must be objectively a real one. James Turner QC and Geraldine More O'Farrell instructed by Rosleys are for the Appellant and Nic Anderson instructed by Philippa Morgan at Lyons Davidson for the Respondent.
The hearing is listed for 20th February 2012.
The hearing is listed for 20th February 2012.
Wednesday, 25 January 2012
Hague Conference 6th Special Commission
The Sixth Special Commission meeting to review the practical operation of the 1980 Hague Child Abduction Convention and the 1996 Protection of Children Convention, opened today in the Hague and will continue until 31st January 2012. The programme which follows up Part I which took place in June 2011 includes presentations and discussions on:
The Conclusions of Part I can be found at: http://www.hcch.net/index_en.php?act=publications.details&pid=5378&dtid=2
- the enforcement of mediated agreements;
- grave risk of harm defence in return proceedings;
- international family relocation; and
- the future of the Malta Process, a dialogue between senior judges and high ranking government officials from Contracting States to the 1980 and 1996 Conventions and non-Contracting States with Sharia based law. The Process is aimed at improving State co-operation in order to assist with resolving difficult cross-border family law disputes in situations where the relevant international legal framework is not applicable.
The Conclusions of Part I can be found at: http://www.hcch.net/index_en.php?act=publications.details&pid=5378&dtid=2
Tuesday, 24 January 2012
ECHR decisions on Article 13b Hague Convention
Two recent decisions of the ECHR seem to show somewhat different approaches in the aftermath of the storm that followed their decision in Neulinger and Shuruk-v-Switzerland (June 2010). Following the concerns expressed by the international legal community the President of the ECtHR made clear in observations to the France - British -Irish Judges Conference in May 2011 that the Court had not intended the decision to be read in the way it had been. These observations were referred to by the UK Supreme Court in the decision of Re E [2011] UKSC 27 [2011] FLR 758 when that court rejected the contention that the effect of Neulinger was to require a full welfare investigation within Hague Convention proceedings.
In Sneersome and Kampanella -v-Italy (App 14737/09) [2011] 2 FLR 1322 the Court considered whether the Italian Courts had acted in breach of the Article 8 rights of the mother and child when using the 'second bite of the cherry' provisions of Art 11 (7) &(8) of BIIIR to over-ride a non-return order made by the Latvian courts in Hague Convention proceedings. The ECtHR concluded that the Italian courts had breached those rights, primarily because they did not deal with the risks identified by the Latvian courts but also because they did not consider the Italian courts had taken sufficient steps to satisfy themselves that the protective measures proposed were adequate to safeguard the child's welfare on a return. The court DID NOT say that a full welfare investigation had to be undertaken.
This case is interesting for the emphasis laid on the need to consider the reasons for refusal of the Hague court to return as required in order to issue the necessary certificate but also for the emphasis on consideration of protective measures under Art 11(4) to reduce or ameliorate a risk. In this respect the approach of the Court mirrors that of the UK Supreme Court in Re E.
In X v. Latvia (ECHR Application 27853/09) decided on December 13, 2011 the ECtHR (Third Section) seemed to go further in finding that the decision of the Latvian courts in making a return order was a breach of Article 8. The majority (6) criticised their failure to give weight to a psychological report on the child and other matters and concluded that as a result of a failure to conduct an in-depth examination of the family situation the making of the return order was a disproportionate interference. Interestingly 2 members of the Section gave dissenting judgments in which they stated that they considered the majority decision was to substitute their own assessment of the best interests of the child with that of the domestic courts. Although the language used by the majority is less emphatic than in the Neulinger stream of cases the decision itself is most unusual for the 'hands on' approach adopted and the way they seem to have acted as a superior appellate court of the sort they are not supposed to be.
Overall the two cases do not add any further fuel to the Neulinger flames - if anything they are evidence of a retreat by the ECtHR from that stream of decisions. They do not seem to me to be as radical as Jeremy Morley sees them: http://www.internationalfamilylawfirm.com/2012/01/hague-abduction-convention-under-threat.html?m=
Of interest to European abduction lawyers in particular is the opening of a route to challenge certificates issued under BIIR Art (7) & (8).
In Sneersome and Kampanella -v-Italy (App 14737/09) [2011] 2 FLR 1322 the Court considered whether the Italian Courts had acted in breach of the Article 8 rights of the mother and child when using the 'second bite of the cherry' provisions of Art 11 (7) &(8) of BIIIR to over-ride a non-return order made by the Latvian courts in Hague Convention proceedings. The ECtHR concluded that the Italian courts had breached those rights, primarily because they did not deal with the risks identified by the Latvian courts but also because they did not consider the Italian courts had taken sufficient steps to satisfy themselves that the protective measures proposed were adequate to safeguard the child's welfare on a return. The court DID NOT say that a full welfare investigation had to be undertaken.
This case is interesting for the emphasis laid on the need to consider the reasons for refusal of the Hague court to return as required in order to issue the necessary certificate but also for the emphasis on consideration of protective measures under Art 11(4) to reduce or ameliorate a risk. In this respect the approach of the Court mirrors that of the UK Supreme Court in Re E.
In X v. Latvia (ECHR Application 27853/09) decided on December 13, 2011 the ECtHR (Third Section) seemed to go further in finding that the decision of the Latvian courts in making a return order was a breach of Article 8. The majority (6) criticised their failure to give weight to a psychological report on the child and other matters and concluded that as a result of a failure to conduct an in-depth examination of the family situation the making of the return order was a disproportionate interference. Interestingly 2 members of the Section gave dissenting judgments in which they stated that they considered the majority decision was to substitute their own assessment of the best interests of the child with that of the domestic courts. Although the language used by the majority is less emphatic than in the Neulinger stream of cases the decision itself is most unusual for the 'hands on' approach adopted and the way they seem to have acted as a superior appellate court of the sort they are not supposed to be.
Overall the two cases do not add any further fuel to the Neulinger flames - if anything they are evidence of a retreat by the ECtHR from that stream of decisions. They do not seem to me to be as radical as Jeremy Morley sees them: http://www.internationalfamilylawfirm.com/2012/01/hague-abduction-convention-under-threat.html?m=
Of interest to European abduction lawyers in particular is the opening of a route to challenge certificates issued under BIIR Art (7) & (8).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)